For the most part, when I told a person I was making my friend Kelly’s wedding cake, his/her reaction was “uhhhhhhhh… have you ever made a wedding cake before?” Well… uhhhhh… no. BUT. Because Kelly has such elegantly simple taste, when I offered to make her wedding cake, I was confident I could handle anything she would want. The fact that this post is appearing on Enchanting Edibles and not Fabulous Flops should tell you that I could, in fact, handle it.
Kelly’s cake was made of:
5.25 POUNDS of butter
17.5 Cups of sugar
35 Eggs
7 teaspoons of vanilla
5 teaspoons of almond extract
21 Cups of flour
5 teaspoons of baking powder
2 teaspoons of salt
7 Cups of milk

Holy cake ingredients, batman. And that’s not even counting the filling or the frosting.
Because I am who I am and I do what I do, I forgot to take photos of the assembly of the actual ingredients. So you can use your imagination on that one. I’ll give you a hint. It looked like cake batter being assembled.
I did use, for the first time, Wilton’s Cake Release. It worked like a charm. The cake was so easy to release from the pan, it was hesitant to even get INTO the pan. It said, “Nooo! Don’t put me in the pan! I’m just gooey delicious batter! Don’t change my chemical make-up by introducing heat! Then the people will EAT me!”

Eh hem.
Well I wrastled it in, and I put the core in. A core is an aluminum piece that sets into the middle of any cake larger than 10″ so that the middle cooks at the same rate as the edges. Another Wilton product worked like a charm. How I love the Wilton. One small design suggestion. The core is closed. So you have to put batter INTO the core in order for you to have a middle piece of the cake. Why not make the core with an open bottom so that it cuts the batter? No weird muffiny thing to deal with.
16-inch pan BARELY fit into my oven. You can see how close it is to the edge. I had to actually lock the oven door in order to keep it closed while it was baking.

Seven cake recipes, six cakes and six weird muffiny things later… I had a fridge full of cake. NOMS. At first I tried to put it in the freezer, but my freezer is most definitely not 16 inches deep. Lose.

Now fast forward about five days. To my amazement, the cake stayed incredibly fresh. I baked on Sunday & decorated on Friday. This cake. Was so. Delicious.
Vicki came over to be my assistant.

She assisted effectively.
Her first task was to cut up cucumbers so we didn’t snack on frosting.

It sort of worked. It’s really hard to focus on cucumbers when you have globs of chocolate buttercream filling at your fingertips. And your fingertips are so close to your taste buds. Mmm…
Anyway.
Chocolate Buttercream Filling ingredients:

Yes, we used ALL 12 pounds of sugar.
The chocolate filling was kind of cool how it came together. First it was a big glob of chocolateness. Then it turned into something that resembled Muddy Buddies. (I LOVE Muddy Buddies!) Then when we added the milk, it turned into super creamy delicious buttercream filling! It was to. die. for.

Now it was time for the very scary part: leveling off the cake. I bought this handy cake leveler from where else but Wilton!? It. Sucked. Now, as I was handing over my debit card to the woman (with really awful facial hair) at Michael’s to buy this thing, I was shaking my head and saying to myself, “It is so stupid to buy this thing. Dad could make something ten times better with three pieces of wood and a guitar string.” For those of you wondering, my Dad is neither MacGuyver nor Jack Bauer, but it is a fact that Superman wears Daryl Kosinski pajamas. Well, I was right. It wasn’t good. I had to level them by hand. That actually worked out fine.

And it left these delicious scraps. What scraps? I didn’t see any scraps.
The leveling process didn’t turn out to be as scary because ~REVELATION~ I can flip the cake OVER to have a flat top! Genius! So I slopped some filling onto the bottom layer…

And flopped on the top layer.
Did you get that?
Slop.
Then Flop.
Evened it all out…

And soon I had another fridge full of cake.

Most delicious fridge ever.
Next I had to apply the crumb coat. This is a thin layer of royal icing that kind of helps “glue” the crumbs down so that when you put the “real” icing on, the crumbs don’t get all mixed up in it. The crumb coat can look like crap. Get it? Crumb Coat Crap. (Apply crap?) It’s the final coat that’s the important part.
Here’s the beginning of the crumb coat. After it’s on, it gets spread all over the entire cake. And the entire kitchen, if you’re really skilled.

I was apparently running too low on time to photograph any further steps. Here’s the Snow White Buttercream Icing I used for the finishing coat.

Let’s sidebar on the bowl for a minute.

I love this bowl. It’s the perfect depth, it has a little ring for hanging onto it, it’s easy to pick up and hold onto; the electric mixer catches all the nooks and crannies & it’s just the perfect bowl. I know it’s hard to envision a bowl even having nooks and/or crannies, but believe me, some bowls you just can’t trust. Unfortunately this bowl is not mine. I have been looking for an equally amazing bowl to add to my wedding registry. The search is ongoing. Standby for updates.
OK, moving on. So I had three layers of this cake in my possession, and because they had grown in size due to the addition of layers and layers of sugar, butter, and… (ok mostly sugar and butter), they no longer fit in the fridge.
Here’s the absolutely most challenging part. We had to transport these layers of cake to the Peruzzi’s Meat Market walk-in cooler in 80-degree weather. Holding my breath the entire way and leaving the camera behind, we drove 25 minutes with the AC on full blast to deliver the cake.
Success. We had to do some touch-ups, but standing in the refrigerator (Vicki freezing her poor bum off) was the best thing I could do for the poor melty cake.
When I got home, the kitchen was a complete disaster.


Everything had a tasty coat of icing on it.
Mom and Dad picked up the cake on Saturday and assembled it in the reception hall while I was tending to the blushing bride.

And she was kind enough to smooth out the icing for me. Cakes don’t travel well. I need a refrigerated van. That would be handy.

Ahhh the cake was complete!

I’m really very happy with it. It’s exactly what Kelly wanted, and it was so super tasty!
